Safety Regulations: How Much Does it Cost When You Fail to Comply?

Safety Regulations: How Much Does it Cost When You Fail to Comply?

Among commercial motor carriers, safety regulations can be a controversial topic. Whether it’s an EOBR mandate or changes to driver fitness rules, you’ll always have vigorous debate on the right way to go. One topic where you’ll find little disagreement is the high cost of noncompliance.

Calculating the cost of noncompliance, however, is not an easy task. There  are so many variables to consider: fleet size, type of vehicle, LTL vs.  truckload, route type (regional, dedicated, long-haul) and trip length, to name  a few. We recently did some research to put numbers to noncompliance, some of  which is cited here.

Fines for Failure to Comply

An obvious way to quantify the costs of noncompliance is by examining fines levied against carriers for violations of DOT safety regulations. In 2015, DOT-regulated truck, bus and motorcoach companies paid $33,751,234 in fines for failure to comply with Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSRs). 

One of the most costly violations is the falsification of a driver log (§395.8[e]). In cases where this was the sole violation cited, carriers paid an average fine of $9,394. Another costly violation is the  transportation of hazardous materials without a properly prepared shipping paper  (§177.817[a]). The average cost in cases where this was the sole  violation: $8,578.

Out-of-Service Costs

Lost revenue associated with out-of-service (OOS) drivers and vehicles is  another cost of failure to comply with FMCSRs.  We estimated the average miles  per hour travelled is 50, and the average revenue per mile is $1.75. The average  revenue per hour (50 mph x $1.75) is $87.50. If a typical out-of-service  violation sidelines a driver or a vehicle for four hours, the  lost revenue per OOS violation is $350.

This number does NOT include other associated costs. Roadside repairs for  out-of-service vehicles may cost three to five times the cost of repairs  performed at a terminal.  Lost driving time is another cost. Not only is a driver failing to produce revenue when he or his vehicle is out-of-service, he’s  also using up his fourteen hours of work time. Delivery delays are another  associated cost that’s difficult to quantify. This is especially problematic for less-than-truckload or dedicated fleets.

Impact on Litigation

According to Rob Moseley, head of the transportation department at Smith Moore Leatherwood, juries are relatively accepting of  truck drivers who make mistakes. Moseley said in a recent interview,  “Juries are much less forgiving when safety issues are ignored  at the management level of the company.” He added, “A trucking company gets to  explain two problems or inconsistencies. After that, the jury doesn’t listen and  will punish the trucking company.”  The result? Damages typically increase.

The costs associated with legal defense are also likely to increase. Not only  must the carrier address the issue under litigation (such as determining who ran  a red light), the carrier must also defend against compliance failures. This may require additional experts and depositions, which, according to Moseley, can add tens of thousands of dollars to the bill.

Additional Financial Impact

Other costs that we’ve calculated include:

  • Increased frequency of inspections and the additional violations identified  during these inspection
  • More detailed inspections (e.g., more Level 1 inspections) and the  associated violations identified
  • Impact on insurance rates
  • Loss of business due to poor CSA scores
  • Reduction in contracted rates for carriers with poor CSA scores

The bottom line for carriers: Invest in compliance. Auditing your drivers’  logs, maintaining accurate and complete records, following a sound drug testing  policy and training your drivers is costly. But it may be less expensive than  the alternative.

Fleet Safety: Putting a Stop to Rolling Stops
Fleet Safety: Putting a Stop to Rolling Stops

Rolling stops are all too tempting for commercial drivers in urban and residential areas. The pressure to m...

Fleet Safety: The Dangers Lurking Inside Your Fleet
Fleet Safety: The Dangers Lurking Inside Your Fleet

Check out some jarring stats and consider these solutions to help improve driving behavior.


Don't miss a thing in 2019. Subscribe to our blog!

First Name
Last Name
Thank you!
Error - something went wrong!